Wondering when to ask for a raise? Timing is everything—and missing the right moment could mean leaving thousands of dollars on the table. In fact, research shows that 82% of employees who asked for a raise received one, often earning $5,000 more than peers who didn’t. So how do you know when it’s the right time to ask?

Here are the 5 biggest signs it’s time to ask for a raise, plus tips to help you make the case with confidence and clarity.

1. You’ve Been With the Company for 2+ Years Without a Raise

If you’ve been working at your job for over two years and haven’t seen a bump in your salary, that’s a red flag. Longevity often signals that you’ve contributed consistently, grown within your role, and taken on more responsibility. Whether you've become the go-to expert in your department or stepped in to lead when needed, that tenure should come with increased pay.

Check your job market value. If you're earning less than others in similar roles, that's an even stronger reason to request a raise.

Tip: Mention your work anniversaries and specific milestones during your raise conversation.

2. Your Responsibilities Have Grown—But Your Pay Hasn’t

Has your job description expanded far beyond what you were originally hired to do? Maybe you started as a marketing assistant but now juggle content planning, campaign strategy, and mentoring interns. Taking on extra duties without a salary increase is common—but also unsustainable.

Tip: Document these changes. Keep track of added tasks, time spent, and successful outcomes. Come prepared to show how your role has evolved.

3. You’re Filling In for Someone Who Left (Long-Term)

If you're covering for a departed coworker—and months have gone by without a replacement—your workload (and value) has clearly increased. Temporary coverage is one thing. But if you’re essentially doing two jobs for one paycheck, it’s time to speak up.

Tip: List the extra responsibilities you've taken on and the impact you've had keeping things running smoothly.

4. You Handle Critical Tasks No One Else Can

Maybe you’re the only certified team member for a specific tool. Or perhaps you’re the one clients insist on working with. When you’re carrying unique or business-critical responsibilities, your employer is depending on you in ways that go beyond a standard job description. That’s leverage.

Tip: Highlight how your exclusive skills or client relationships make you an irreplaceable asset—and why your pay should reflect that.

5. You Receive Consistent Praise—but No Pay Bump

If your manager is regularly complimenting your work during check-ins or team meetings, that's a strong sign they value what you bring to the table. But compliments don’t pay the bills. When positive feedback doesn’t come with a raise, it’s okay to take initiative.

Tip: You might say, “I’m grateful for the recognition I’ve received. I’d love to talk about aligning my compensation with my contributions.”

When in Doubt, Trust the Signs—and Start the Conversation

Asking for a raise doesn’t mean you’re greedy or pushy. It means you value your work, recognize your contributions, and want fair compensation. These five signs are your green lights. Don’t wait for permission—create the opportunity by starting a respectful, well-prepared conversation.

You deserve to grow—not just in your role, but in your paycheck too.

Ready for your next move? Check out our guides on salary negotiation tips, how to prep for your raise conversation, or share your story in the comments.